You've probably received your fair share of "Hi [Your Name]" emails that feel more like automated blasts than genuine messages. Personalization is more than slapping a name at the top of a generic message. Sure, using someone's name might have worked back in the day, but people are smarter now.

They know when they're just another name in a mass email campaign. 

The kind of cold email personalization that grabs attention and drives results requires more than knowing your audience’s first name.

Luckily, we'll show you how to go beyond the basics and create these emails that stand out in a crowded inbox. 

By the end of this piece, you'll have all the tools you need to create part of the elite 2% of emails that truly connect with their recipients.

Aside from learning how to write the perfect messages, measuring the impact of personalization in cold emails is another key aspect that we’ll cover here, so let’s get to it.

Why Personalization Matters

When you tailor your messages to each recipient, you're not just sending an email; you're starting a conversation. Businesses that use personalization see up to a $20 return on every $1 spent, and there's a good reason for that.

Behind every business email address is a human being, and humans respond to personalization.

Studies, such as one conducted by The University of Texas, suggest that our preference for personalized experiences stems from the desire for control.

Personalized content gives us the feeling of being in control of the content and products we consume. This desire for control is why getting personalized material, rather than generic ones, appeals to us.

There are different levels of personalization, from basic techniques like using the recipient's name to advanced strategies that tailor the entire message to the recipient's interests and needs. 

For example, marketing leader,Mark Borum was able to increase cold email response rates by 142% by implementing personalized strategies.

His success shows that understanding what makes a great personalized cold emailing and using it effectively, significantly impacts response rates.

So, why should you care about personalizing your cold emails? 

Higher Response Rates

Wouldn't you be more likely to respond to an email that speaks directly to your needs and interests? That's the power of personalization. It grabs attention and gets results.

Improved Reputation

Think of personalization as a way to show you care. When you tailor your emails, you're showing the recipient that you've taken the time to understand them. It's a great way to build a positive reputation.

Increased Sales

Personalized emails are more persuasive. By addressing the recipient's specific pain points and needs, you're more likely to convince them to take action, whether it's buying your product or booking a meeting.

Better Customer Relationships

Personalization goes a long way in building strong relationships. It shows your customers that you see them as individuals, not just another email address in your list.

The best part is how these benefits apply to anyone engaging in cold email outreach, whether you're reaching out to potential customers, partners, or collaborators.

Key Elements of Personalized Cold Emails

Now that we've covered why personalization is so important, let's talk about the key elements that make up a successful personalized cold email. 

These features can make or break your email outreach efforts, so pay close attention!

Compelling Subject Lines

Your subject line is the first thing your recipient sees, so make it count. You know those emails that make you stop scrolling and actually open them? That's the power of a compelling subject line. 

Surprisingly, close to 10% of professionals worldwide did not send any emails with personalized subject lines in 2023, despite personalized emails getting an 82% higher open rate.

So, make your subject lines stand out by addressing the recipient directly and piquing their curiosity.

Personalization Attributes

Personalization attributes are key pieces of information that inject a sense of individual attention into your emails. By demonstrating that you've invested time in understanding the recipient's unique interests and achievements, these attributes significantly enhance the personal touch of your message. Whether it’s referencing a notable recent blog post they’ve written, celebrating their latest professional milestone, or any other personal accolade, the inclusion of these details signals a genuine effort to connect on a personal level.

Attributes can vary widely in nature and application, catering to the specific context and goals of your email. They can be:

  • Custom Attributes: These are tailor-made for each recipient, such as a distinctive opening line that resonates with their recent activities or a unique link that aligns with their interests. Custom attributes ensure your email stands out by directly appealing to the individual’s current priorities or achievements.

  • Computed Attributes: These involve elements that are calculated based on certain criteria, like suggesting a meeting time that is exactly two business days ahead. Computed attributes add a dynamic layer to your emails, making your proposals timely and relevant.

  • Standard Attributes: These include basic but essential details like the recipient’s title, company name, and first name. Even though they are more generic, standard attributes are fundamental to personalizing your email at a basic level, ensuring that at the very least, your email addresses the recipient correctly and professionally.

Pain Points and Offering Solutions

Finally, don't forget to address the recipient's pain points and offer solutions in your emails.

Whether it's a common challenge in their industry or a specific problem they're facing, showing that you understand their pain points and offering a solution can make your email irresistible.

For example, if you're reaching out to a marketing agency, you might address their struggles with client retention and offer a solution like your customer relationship management software.

By showing that you understand their challenges and have a solution, you're more likely to grab their attention.

Proper A/B Testing for Personalization

A/B testing isn't just for ad campaigns; it's also a powerful tool in your cold email arsenal. Also known as split testing, it is a method of comparing two versions of an email against each other to determine which one performs better.

It's like trying out two different routes to work to see which one gets you there faster.

A/B testing allows you to test different elements of your emails to see which ones drive the best results.

With cold email campaigns, A/B testing isn't just about testing different subject lines or call-to-action buttons (although those are important too). It's also about testing different messaging styles and personalization strategies. 

In the tweet below, which messaging do you think the prospect would be more keen to respond to?

Tweet sample screenshot

Of course, the email that feels like you've been using the software with them to know what problems they're facing or might face. 

Testing different strategies is a no-brainer because personalization isn't one-size-fits-all. What works for one recipient might not work for another.

Whether it's mentioning their recent blog post or addressing a specific pain point, experimenting with different approaches can help you find the sweet spot.

You should also test to:

  • Better Understand Your Audience: A/B testing allows you to gain valuable insights into what resonates with your audience.By testing different personalization strategies, you can learn more about their preferences and tailor your messages accordingly.

  • Improve Engagement Rates: By testing different elements of your cold emails, you can identify which ones lead to higher engagement rates. This can help you craft more effective emails that drive action.

  • Increase Conversion Rates: Ultimately, the goal of any cold email campaign is to convert recipients into customers.A/B testing can help you identify which strategies are most effective at driving conversions, helping you achieve a successful cold email campaign.

So, when A/B testing in cold email campaigns, what are the key things to keep in mind? Let's break it down:

Sample Sizes

First things first, make sure your sample sizes are big enough to give you reliable results. Testing with too few recipients won't give you an accurate picture of what's working and what's not.

Metrics to Track

Decide upfront what metrics you'll be keeping an eye on. Whether it's open rates, click-through rates, or conversion rates, having clear metrics in mind will help you measure the success of your tests.

Duration of Tests

Patience is key here. Give your tests enough time to run their course. Rushing through tests can lead to inaccurate results, so be patient and let your tests do their thing.

Best Practices for Personalizing Cold Emails

Personalizing your cold emails can significantly improve your chances of success, but you need to do it right. 

Here are some best practices to keep in mind:

Research the Target Audience

Before you hit send, take the time to research your target audience.

Twitter post image
Yes, generic personalization backfires and reveals that you haven't done your homework. 

Leverage Recipient's Preferences and Past Interactions

Use any available information about your recipients' preferences and past interactions with your brand to tailor your message. Mentioning a previous interaction or highlighting a product they've shown interest in can go a long way.

Use Social Proof and Personalized Details

Incorporate social proof and personalized details into your emails to build trust and credibility.

Whether it's mentioning mutual connections or referencing specific achievements, personalized details can make your emails stand out.

Implement Clear Calls to Action

Ensuring your recipient understands the next steps is pivotal in the design of your cold email. It's crucial to avoid cluttering your message with multiple Calls to Action (CTAs); instead, aim for a singular, clear, and direct ask. This simplicity makes it easier for recipients to engage with your email and take the desired action without any confusion.

For instance, achieving a fast and effective response to a cold email often hinges on the clarity and directness of your CTA. Crafting a message that straightforwardly conveys your ask can significantly enhance your chances of getting a reply and receiving valuable information, such as a mobile number, within a short timeframe.

To get inspired and see examples of compelling CTAs that have proven to be effective, we encourage you to explore our comprehensive CTA Swipe File. This resource is designed to provide you with actionable insights and templates that can be tailored to fit your specific email outreach strategy, ensuring your calls to action resonate with your audience and elicit the desired responses.

Bonus tip: Quickmail's automated scheduling and AI + sub-campaigns can help streamline this process, allowing you to test and optimize your personalization elements efficiently.

Personalization's Impact on Deliverability

When done right, personalization improves engagement and signals to email service providers that your emails are relevant to recipients.

However, personalization done poorly can have the opposite effect, leading to emails being flagged as spam.

To maintain a positive sender reputation with personalized cold emails, hone in on tools such as Quickmail's inbox rotation feature.

This feature helps to distribute emails evenly across different IP addresses, reducing the risk of being marked as spam due to sending volume.

Other challenges to expect include:

  • The risk of emails landing in spam folders: Use spam filter testing tools to ensure your emails are not flagged as spam.

  • Managing sending limits: Keep track of your sending limits and avoid sending too many emails at once.

  • Automated follow-ups: Use automated follow-up sequences to ensure that your emails are being delivered and opened.

Measuring the Impact of Personalization

As Email expert, Chase, confirms here, the goal of personalization is to speak directly to one person, one company, one lead, whichever applies.

But these common mistakes can hinder your efforts:

  • Over-reliance on first name personalization

  • Failing to segment your audience effectively

  • Using outdated or incorrect information

Personalized cold emails contribute to higher ROI compared to generic outreach.

For example, personalized email subject lines can boost open rates by 50%. This increased engagement translates to higher ROI. 

To measure the ROI of personalized cold email campaigns, track metrics such as:

  • Open rates: Open rates indicate how many recipients are actually opening your cold emails, giving you insight into the effectiveness of your subject lines and overall email appeal.

  • Click-through rates: Click-through rates show how many recipients are taking action by clicking on links within your cold emails, indicating the level of interest and engagement generated by your content and call-to-action.

  • Conversion rates: Conversion rates measure the percentage of recipients who not only open and click through your cold emails but also complete a desired action.

  • Revenue generated: This metric tracks the actual revenue generated from your cold email campaign, allowing you to directly tie the campaign's success to financial gains for your business and evaluate its return on investment (ROI).

  • Cost per acquisition: Cost per acquisition calculates the average cost incurred to acquire a new customer or lead through your cold email campaign, helping you assess the efficiency and profitability of your email marketing efforts.

Final Thoughts

A cold email doesn't have to feel impersonal. Personalization in cold email can transform your outreach, making even the most serious topics feel warm and engaging.

With Quickmail, enhancing email personalization and overcoming common challenges like deliverability, dropped balls, missed replies, and poor results is easier than ever. 

Leverage Quickmail to maximize the impact of your cold email campaigns and see your engagement and ROI soar. Start personalizing your cold emails today and see the difference it can make!